Amish schoolteacher Lilly Lapp is tired of weddings afraid of horses and immersed in caring for her depressed mother. But when handsome horse breeder Jacob Wyse rescues her from a dangerous accident Lilly discovers a renewed interest in life and love. Yet Jacob has lost the one true love of his life to another man and doesn't care to expose himself to the vulnerabilities of loving again. God works to bring this unlikely pair into a sweet romance.