Callie Creighton ditches her Chicago lifestyle and highly successful career to be her best friend's bridesmaid in her hometown of Plymouth, Indiana. There she reunites with the childhood church that nurtured her in Christ and runs headlong into her past. Namely, Jason Kenton, the Mr. Hottie of her high school class she secretly adored and publicly preached at…and the last person she wants to see now. No longer the bad boy, Jason has worked hard to make up for past mistakes—giving his life to Christ, mentoring young musicians, and earning his master's degree. Except leaving the past behind isn't so simple in a small town…especially when green-star-eyed Callie returns to Plymouth. Is Jason really the new man he claims to be? And a decade after falling off the Miss Blueberry float, will Callie find herself falling for him?