A printed response to Croswell's remarks, published under the pseudonym of Simon the Tanner but believed to be authored by Thomas Prentice, is also available. Its title is "A letter to the Reverend Andrew Croswell occasioned by his Brief remarks on the satyrical drollery, last commencement day, with especial reference to the character of Stephen, the preacher, which occasioned such extravagant mirth."