Cupid Jones had been helping the people of Valentine, Kansas, find true love for years. But when rugged, love-shy rancher Burke Riley reached the Valentine post office to collect his mail-order bride-to-be, Cupid had matched her to another! Furious, Burke demanded that the maddening, meddling postmistress with the outrageous name right her wrong and find him a substitute spouse, pronto. Confident in her special powers, Cupid vowed she would. But soon the well-intentioned matchmaker found herself married to the sexy, confounding man, and worse, struck by her own love-tipped arrow! With her powers in jeopardy, would Cupid's marriage to Burke end her matchmaking days, or prove to be the best match of them all?