Daphne and Oliver have almost nothing in common. Daphne attends her town's public high school; Oliver is a student at the elite Sacred Heart. Daphne is a quiet, bookish drama nerd; Oliver is the popular, outgoing mascot for the Sacred Heart football team. It seems unlikely that their paths would ever cross, but one single event has bound them inextricably to one another. Daphne's older sister, Emily, and Oliver's older brother, Jason, former lovers, committed suicide together seven years earlier.